Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Your pessimism and apathy is both disheartening and infuriating.

Make enough of a stink, and people listen. That is one of the few immutable laws of politics. If you are not getting the desired results, you're not making enough of a stink yet.



- 36 million people across the globe march in protest, Iraq: still invaded. (Source https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protests_against_the_Iraq_War)

- Millions protest regularly, Guantanamo: still open (Couldn't be bothered to source exact numbers, but here're some pictures: https://www.google.com/search?q=Protests+Guantanamo&source=l...)

- Ditto patriot act, status: passed

Exactly how much of a stink did you have in mind? Perhaps people setting themselves on fire en mass? Getting run over by tanks?


Boo hoo - protests were had, and it did not change things. So you keep working and keep trying, it's not like you get to just show up at a protest and everything magically gets better. It takes money, time, and hard work.


I was responding to the parent, a fact you seem to have taken out of context.

Care to elaborate on what possibly more could have been done in any of the cited examples that wasn't already done? Or indeed how you propose that "money, time, and hardwork" (sic) would help? I'd also be interested in why you feel money should be involved in preserving the right of any sentient being not to be tortured, invaded or denied the right to protest when the former happens.


> Care to elaborate on what possibly more could have been done in any of the cited examples that wasn't already done?

You don't always get your way, you know? You win some, you lose some. That doesn't mean that ... there's no democracy and nothing is possible and woe is us, etc... etc... blah blah blah.

> why you feel money should be involved in preserving the right of any sentient being not to be tortured, invaded or denied the right to protest when the former happens.

We're not talking about an ideal world (duh), but about the one we inhabit. In this one, sometimes justice is difficult to obtain, and requires sacrifice.

So you can either get off your ass and do something, or you can sit around complaining on HN. The former sometimes won't work, or won't accomplish what you had hoped to. The latter is guaranteed to accomplish nothing.


Perhaps you should re-read what you're responding to.

I'm certainly not complaining unless that's how you define discussion that runs contrary to your interests, in which case: why are you here?

Also nice edit :-P


Doing the same thing over and over expecting a different result is the definition of "protest."


Utterly disagree - massive large scale "protest" is what got SOPA killed.

I have yet to see the cynics suggest a better reasonable course of action.

I also wish that people who have nothing constructive to add would kindly STFU instead of dumping all over everyone else's ideas and enthusiasm. I can think of no better way to ensure things never change.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: