Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Kivo: Simple document feedback in your browser (kivo.com)
31 points by pea on May 30, 2014 | hide | past | favorite | 7 comments


Interesting. Some comments:

1) It doesn't mention what file types it accepts. Since it says "presentations" I'm tempted to think .PPT, but some tools for presentations (like SpeakerDeck.com) take .PDF.

2) Why presentations? Why not documents (e.g. word processing files)? I haven't used Google Docs, but if it doesn't have feedback capability it seems like documents might be a more fruitful niche than presentations.

3) Perhaps related to (2), would it make more sense to highlight the text you want to comment on rather than drawing a box around it (which doesn't work so well if the text wraps to the next line)?


Thanks a lot for the feedback!

1) Thanks, I will fix that; I agree it is not clear. We accept pptx, ppt, and pdf.

2) With early users, we found that content creation of Word documents can happen relatively easily outside of Word; this is not the case with PowerPoint. There are a couple of great online Word processors, and GDocs does a good job of annotating text. PowerPoint is different because it is still the ubiquitous way to make a presentation, a piece of software which has few alternatives, and currently no decent solution exists for this pain-point.

3.) That's a good idea. We did boxes first of all, because it's a one-size-fits-all approach and we wanted to keep it simple. We will be adding more specific annotations (text, shapes, graphs, etc.) in the future.

Thanks again for reaching out -- and feel free to email me (leo@kivo.com) if you have any more questions!


Hey! We've been using Kivo @ SketchDeck to discuss our designs with clients and it's been working well, thanks. Are you guys going to add versioning?


Hi guys -- yes, version-control is being added in in the next few weeks. Ping me on leo@kivo.com if you need any help, or have any ideas re what you guys would like it to look like.


Awesome work! To edit an annotation shall I mark it as resolved and then create a new one?


Hey! Yeah, for now that would work. I can also add in editing if you think it would be useful? Shouldn't take long. If you have any more feedback or feature requests ping me on leo@kivo.com. Cheers!


Looking good! A mobile app would make it sing :)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: