Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Just to confirm, the article doesn't really make it clear (or I'm just dense), but are they carrying broadband through power lines?


No - the data goes through fiber optic cables.

https://www.epb.net/power/home/products/smart-grid/


No, I think the electric company built a fiber network to manage their electric grid and then they decided to extend it to homes and businesses.


I guess the real question is then: Does allowing home/business users onto the same network that manages the electrical grid a good idea (from an OpSec point of view)? Does this make it easier to hack the electric grid? What happens to the electric grid when the network becomes congested?


One would hope they would be physically segregating the network and using different fiber strands for SCADA vs home/business users. I would be nervous even if it was logically separated using something like vlans at layer 2; you're one bad configuration change away from possibly damaging consequences.


My thought is that this digs into the idea that they 'just decided to' offer Fiber-to-the-Premises after they realized that they had built a fiber network. Or is this a non-issue (i.e. adding new strands is trivial / cheap once the infrastructure is there or maybe SOP is to just lay lots of strands, because the strands are cheap)?


Fiber optic cable is manufactured with anywhere between 1 and 288 strands in the bundle; I believe its most likely a non-issue.


This is correct.


Broadband over Powerline only exists in Ohio and Illinois due to the interference it creates on different radio frequencies.

http://broadbandnow.com/powerline


Without actually knowing, either this (PowerLine), or they use the existing resources (cable pipes, wiring posts, ...) to run fiber or other wires to their customers without having to invest in digging or putting up poles.

This saves not only the construction costs, but also allow speedy installation as the time needed to get digging/building permits falls away. It's dead fast to wire an entire city area with FTTH if you already have a network of pipes for electrical wiring.


& the best part: It's to every home by default, regardless of locale. You can be in the woods in a trailer and have gigabit :)





Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: