Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

To be clear: Serious vitamin deficiencies can cause serious problems (scurvy in the case of vitamin C, rickets in the case of vitamin D, beriberi for vitamin B).1 But if you live in the developed world and eat a normal diet — even a pretty unhealthy one — you will be nowhere near this kind of deficiency.

I live in Canada and eat a normal diet. My blood 25-hydroxyvitamin D level was 22 nM. I had symptoms of hypovitaminosis D which went away after taking 150 kIU over the course of a month, at which point my blood level of 25-hydroxyvitamin D had increased to 76 nM.

Sure, this is pure anecdote, but it proves that it is possible to be deficient.



Canada is so north that at this time of the year it is already not having UVB ray penetration, which is required for the body to make Vitamin D.


I'm in Canada and the UV index (which is based on UVB levels) is still hitting 4 or 5 on clear days. That is above the level where you are recommended to wear clothing, hats, sunscreen, etc to avoid burning. How do you figure that is not enough to produce vitamin D?


Did you take pure vitamin D or something naturally high in it such as fish oil?


Considering that vitamin D is typically measured in nanograms, it would be pretty difficult to take pure vitamin D! But to answer the question I think you're asking: I take pills. Now that I'm on a "maintenance dose" of 1000 IU/day I could theoretically get it from dietary sources if I worked hard; but when I was placed on 5000 IU/day there was no possible way to get enough that way.


You don't want fish oil for supplemental vitamin D, you want cod liver. It's usually on the shelf next to the fish oil.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: