Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It would have collateral effects (disabling all wireless activity in the area of jamming), but it's absolutely possible.



>disabling all wireless activity in the area of jamming

Only on the jammed frequencies. Police radios and such will keep working.


Weeelll... that depends on a lot of things. Any jammer with the power to work over a meaningful radius in this context is probably going to throw out lots of spurious emissions in neighboring bands.


Police Radios (and GMRS, and FRS) are not neighboring bands to 802.11


Does China use the same frequency bands as US?


Looking at this document (http://www.ncc.gov.tw/english/files/07060/92_070605_1.pdf) it's not immediately clear. A ctrl-F for "emergency" and "police" yields no results.

However, there is a FRS band which is the same as the US.

Moreover, the bands used by "push-to-talk" radios are ones that transmit reasonably far for lowish power and penetrate walls. No reason to think they'll be different worldwide.


That document is about the Republic of China (Taiwan), not about Hong Kong or the People's Republic of China.


I think he was talking about the surrounding businesses. Jamming or interference with business operations might provoke a flight of capital.

Hong Kong is rather concentrated.


The police can blame the protesters for all the troubles - block traffic, stopping commerce, blocking cell/wifi/BT service. From what I read, not much different than the police strategy used the 99% protest in Wall Street.


I don't recall the US banning twitter or censoring any social network. No prohibition of coverage.

Not to mention there was a tremendous amount of sympathetic coverage. Time 2011 person of the year was the protester. It was a huge conversation that entered the common narrative.

Apples and Oranges. Yeah, there are best practices for dealing with crowds and there needs to be security at huge protests. The cloak and the shield is a very fine line.

I know for a fact in Canada there was no wifi/cell/BT blocking. And I cannot find a reputable article the provides any evidence that this occurred.


He is saying that they blamed the protestors for inconveniences caused by police actions not that the police in the US blocked cell service.

The strategy for dealing with the protests in the US was just to wait them out and then when the media got bored they sent in the police to clear out the camps while people weren't paying attention.


I think he was saying all of the above, but I am not sure any of the strategies he mentioned will work in Hong Kong.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: