Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Well is US economy on the verge of collapse.

Because I see people putting crazy hours here as well with only 2 weeks or less of vacation time.

> - They spend hours choosing the text of buttons,

Hello bike shedding. Ever been to any meeting with "senior" management. Those people just don't know how to shut the fuck up or admit they "don't understand" so they latch on and start pronouncing orders about stuff they understand -- button colors. Happens in US, China, Africa, Europe.

> - they're expected to learn the Way We Do Things In This Company until their 30s,

Ok but then they have learnt them and are good to go for another 30 or 40 years until they retire. Having job security is no joke when health insurance, housing, family is involved. There is something to be sad about it. It might even be worth a salary cut.

> - they attend work for extended hours,

Depending what you compare to. American workers also work what Europeans might consider crazy and unreasonable hours (if you add vacation or lack of into the mix especially).

> - the workforce capacities are planned dozens of years in advance,

I have seen large military industrial contractors lay off thousands in a swift hand move because some major contract from US govt got lost. The other extreme is you know not plan in advance and only plan 2 years ahead then let everyone go and re-hire/re-train/re-certify new ones. Is that better. I am not sure yet.

> - decision-making is centralized in the hands of the major companies, investments are interlocked between company-arranged rents, company-arranged investments and company-arranged paperwork,

Wait, isn't most of the US economy run by large organization which make decision not unlike dictatorships. Centralized with the classic pyramid management scheme. I guess if all we do is read HN we might get a bit of a wrong impression about how the economy and labor market works here.

> - and they have competition from foreign products which were produced by more officient economies, e.g. the iPhone

So China (FoxConnn)? Yeah China is great. They are efficient but that is in part because they are willing to cut corners and disregard safety or health standards.

But yeah I get it, you mean to say "Apple" and by proxy -- US. Well they can't do everything well. Their car businesses are doing well. Look at Ford, GM etc vs Honda and Toyota. Perhaps there the situation is reversed.



If you suscribe to some economic theories, workforce capacity planning years in advance sounds disastrously inefficient.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: