Mm, I'm not sure. These are slides, presumably designed to go alongside a talk, which could have fleshed out the points better. If you consider them as being summaries of what a speaker's saying, it makes much more sense.
Fwiw, of the six bullets, I see three which are clearly subjective, one which is a clear advantage of gerrit, and two which I don't really know enough about to refute.
When it comes down to build systems, I think it's very easy to spend a lot of time moving sideways or backwards - and if the tool you're moving to has deficiencies compared with what you had before, it can be very frustrating. Certainly, if the tool people want you to move to offers few advantages over your current infrastructure, a quick dismissal is reasonable.
Getting set up with their current contribution system might seem a little clunky, but I don't think it's particularly hard to do, and definitely seems like a 'run-once' thing. Once it's set up, it seems to integrate into a workflow well.
Their contributors will have their current workflows set up nicely - and unless github's issues system has compelling advantages, it's definitely not worth them switching due to the temporary loss in productivity.
Fwiw, of the six bullets, I see three which are clearly subjective, one which is a clear advantage of gerrit, and two which I don't really know enough about to refute.
When it comes down to build systems, I think it's very easy to spend a lot of time moving sideways or backwards - and if the tool you're moving to has deficiencies compared with what you had before, it can be very frustrating. Certainly, if the tool people want you to move to offers few advantages over your current infrastructure, a quick dismissal is reasonable.
Getting set up with their current contribution system might seem a little clunky, but I don't think it's particularly hard to do, and definitely seems like a 'run-once' thing. Once it's set up, it seems to integrate into a workflow well.
Their contributors will have their current workflows set up nicely - and unless github's issues system has compelling advantages, it's definitely not worth them switching due to the temporary loss in productivity.