I'm not sure I understood point #1. Do you mean that the periodicity is too consistent to support the theory of an orbiting body, because an orbiting body would have a less consistent orbit? If so, that's very interesting.
Pertaining point #2, I'm not very confident in any empirical data observed at this point in human evolution. It's not to say that scientists aren't working very hard to learn things, but moments like http://www.theguardian.com/science/2015/feb/26/found-a-black... tell me that we're going to go through many more "we're absolutely sure / wait, we were wrong" moments, especially when pertaining astronomy and ontology, both fields with many more unknowns than true facts.
Pertaining point #2, I'm not very confident in any empirical data observed at this point in human evolution. It's not to say that scientists aren't working very hard to learn things, but moments like http://www.theguardian.com/science/2015/feb/26/found-a-black... tell me that we're going to go through many more "we're absolutely sure / wait, we were wrong" moments, especially when pertaining astronomy and ontology, both fields with many more unknowns than true facts.