Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Cars charge overnight, which is a trough in electric demand. power plants prefer even loads. So car charging loads would be much less stressful than, say, growing population 10% and increasing peak demand.



"which is a trough in electric demand"

Except, with some of the suggested solutions, like rooftop solar/etc, we know that over time it causes the normal power usage to invert (see germany, which no longer has a mid-day peak).

That is, the trough is no longer at night, but in the middle of the day.

Ever barring this: think of this another way: If you suddenly increase nighttime usage by several thousand percent, it's unlikely to be a trough anymore, and pretty far into a spike.

THe carport amperage/voltage is usually around 240v/30 amp. This is a lot, and definitely a ton more than the average power usage of a home at rest or even with the AC on.

At that voltage/amperage, it would take 10+ hours to charge an 85kwh battery

If you go to 240/50 amp, it's about 7 hours, but again, even more of a factor than the average hours residential usage.

This is like having 4-5 high end electric oven on full blast for 7 hours.

(or in maker terms: i have a really nice 3hp table saw, really nice 3hp jointer, planer, cyclone dust collector, cnc machine, vacuum clamp, etc. Having them *all running at once takes less power than the carport :P)

I would bet, in fact, that it would shift peak residential to nighttime by a significant factor (to put some perspective on this: average residential usage is like 25-30kwh a day, so 85 at night would definitely be "huge")

(Again, it's not that i don't think there are solutions, but in grand california tradition, they chase some magically happy utopia without actually ever planning for the long term consequences, then act shocked when they happen)




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: