> our lack of capacity of understand complex images, compared to text
I'm not sure I agree with this. Not as a fundamental law, at least. I find complex text pretty difficult to understand. Sure, I can read the words or even expressions, but to really understand how everything is connected and how the data and control flows through what's written, I find that incredibly difficult. A large part of programming is keeping that contextual information in my head so that I don't have to re-evaluate it all again.
Which is the reason why I love pen & paper and boxes & lines when I try to map out some code, a data structure, algorithm or idea. Obviously everyone is different, but for me, when things get too complex, I reach for images and diagrams to help me understand and form a clear mental model of what's going on or what I want.
Having said that, I've yet to find a visual programming language that does this. When I used Max/MSP a number of years back, I found it helped me think in "code" as I could map out ideas visually, reducing the need for pen and paper, but it had a ton of shortcomings. It gave me a glimpse of what it could be though, and I think the problems could be solved to a point where I can skip pen and paper altogether. We're not there yet, but if you think about how much time and effort went into making textual languages, its no wonder visual languages are so far behind. Also, its clear that not every task is well suited to visual languages, so the best environment would need to be a mix of both.
I'm not sure I agree with this. Not as a fundamental law, at least. I find complex text pretty difficult to understand. Sure, I can read the words or even expressions, but to really understand how everything is connected and how the data and control flows through what's written, I find that incredibly difficult. A large part of programming is keeping that contextual information in my head so that I don't have to re-evaluate it all again.
Which is the reason why I love pen & paper and boxes & lines when I try to map out some code, a data structure, algorithm or idea. Obviously everyone is different, but for me, when things get too complex, I reach for images and diagrams to help me understand and form a clear mental model of what's going on or what I want.
Having said that, I've yet to find a visual programming language that does this. When I used Max/MSP a number of years back, I found it helped me think in "code" as I could map out ideas visually, reducing the need for pen and paper, but it had a ton of shortcomings. It gave me a glimpse of what it could be though, and I think the problems could be solved to a point where I can skip pen and paper altogether. We're not there yet, but if you think about how much time and effort went into making textual languages, its no wonder visual languages are so far behind. Also, its clear that not every task is well suited to visual languages, so the best environment would need to be a mix of both.