Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I knew the UK was going sharply downhill with the surveillance state nonsense, but that far already?

Wow - I have even more respect for the people who risk their lives to damage and tear down government surveillance cameras for the common good.



People here don't care.

When I read the story that schools in my area had been installing spyware on students phones I assumed it was some kind of isolated thing. But my GF works in schools so I asked her if she knew of this app and she was like, "oh yeah, all the kids have it".

I found this utterly insane but she seemed to think it was a good thing if it could be used to protect kids. And I guess I get the argument, but you could say the same thing about the government installing CCTV in everyone's homes... You need to draw lines, especially when there's an expectation of privacy.

This is my concern with facial recognition in shops too. If I go into a shop I expect people to see my face, so a simple CCTV system seems fine. I even expect people who know me might recognise who I am, so again, if a human being I've interacted with before identifies me on the CCTV system I'm okay with this. What I don't think people expect is to be identified by some automated national biometric system which checks to see if you've ever stolen anything before so it can alert security, while also trying to understand your emotions and individual purchasing habits.

I used to work for a large highstreet retail org and was literally pitched on a system which could identify our customers and tell us how they feel about their shopping experience and their shopping habits.

But like I say, no one cares. I've spoken about this with people so often and they act like I'm some kind of privacy lunatic. That said, people here get very animated if someone can access data they've personally shared to Facebook and made publicly available.


Some people choose to blindly trust the government and decide whatever it does is for the best and has no downsides. To quote someone I asked (unsuccessfully) for a referendum signature against a surveillance law, "If I can't trust the government anymore, then who can I trust?"




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: